I accidentally shot a guy, you have to press circle to punch, not R2. Then I decided to kill them, and loot them. They killed my horse, and me. Then I accidentally got on the wrong horse, which is stealing, I surrendered, and they took my $15 or so. You get to see him in jail. You don’t actually get to move around in your cell and stuff though.
If you don’t have enough to pay it, surrender and you’ll have no money but not bounty. Or run away and get killed.
The first bounty was $30, then the second one added $20. I was trying to sell a necklace, but the general store doesn’t buy them apparently. What happens if you have $0 and surrender?
Games are hard to play with a low IQ.